Update browser for a secure Made experience

It looks like you may be using a web browser version that we don't support. Make sure you're using the most recent version of your browser, or try using of these supported browsers, to get the full Made experience: Chrome, Firefox, Safari, or Edge.

Program Notes

London Symphony Orchestra

Program

George Walker Sinfonia No 5, 'Visions'

Felix Mendelssohn Violin Concerto in E minor, op. 64 

Allegro molto appassionato 
Andante 
Allegretto non troppo – Allegro molto vivace

-Intermission-

Gustav Mahler Symphony No 1 in D major, 'Titan'

Langsam, schleppend
Frisch 
Feierlich und gemessen, ohne zu schleppen
 Stürmisch bewegt

PROGRAM NOTES

George Walker (1922-2018): Sinfonia No 5

On July 2015, a young American white supremacist shot nine members of the Emanuel African Methodist Episcopal Church in Charleston, South Carolina. The 94-year-old composer George Walker had visited Charleston not long before this chilling, deranged event, and it shook him so deeply that he decided to channel his anger and anxiety into an orchestral composition. But this would be no pious white liberal protest song. Walker was black, and he felt the shock of this atrocity in his blood and bones.

Walker decided to channel his feelings into an orchestral work that reflected both the anxiety and unease of the times and his own sense of rage, bewilderment and grief. It became the fifth of his orchestral ‘Sinfonias’ – striking that the very title should both acknowledge and refuse to engage directly with the White European-American symphonic tradition. It would be an intensely political ‘Fifth’, like Beethoven’s, yet also not like Beethoven’s.

At first, Walker thought of having his Fifth Sinfonia accompanied by a video of Charleston and its tragedy, created by his friend, the photographer Frank Schramm, and with a fragmentary text sequence, read by a group of soloists. But the video idea was eventually dropped. Sinfonia No 5 has been recorded with the recited text, and it’s certainly powerful, but the music is quite strong enough to speak for itself. It’s composed in a style which in many ways seems modernist: agitated, restless, it jumps and swerves from idea to idea, as though intent on defying orthodox symphonic developmental logic.

Yet the effect isn’t fragmentary: the music is carried forward, it seems, by the visceral power of the emotions it taps and releases. And it’s surprisingly direct in its effect – listeners who know the plays of Samuel Beckett may be reminded of the terrifying Not I, in which a mouth, suspended in blackness, attempts manically to give form to some half-defined traumatic experience. At the head of the score, Walker wrote the words ‘in memoriam…’ (‘in memory’), a tribute to the Charleston victims, but also to the countless other victims of racial violence, and an expression of horror that such senseless crimes still continue. ‘The only lesson we learn from history’, said the philosopher Georg Hegel, ‘is that we learn nothing from history’. George Walker’s Sinfonia No 5 is the agonised expression of that terrible insight in music.  

— Stephen Johnson

Felix Mendelssohn (1809-1847): Violin Concerto

Mendelssohn wanted his adopted hometown of Leipzig to have a thriving musical life. One of his key allies in that project was a violinist called Ferdinand David. Mendelssohn hired him as a teacher for his music school and a leader for his orchestra.

David was among the best violinists of his day. His playing was so seductive that it led Mendelssohn to convert a piano concerto he was writing into a concerto for violin instead.

Mendelssohn prized order, balance and sensitivity in music. His violin concerto embodies those principles while still managing to sound fervent and joyous.

The composer wanted the piece to sound fluent and continuous, like a flowing stream. Unusually, all three movements are linked: the first two by a single note on the bassoon, the second and third third via a short intermezzo. 

The Violin Concerto is also a masterpiece of economy. The soloist enters almost immediately with the concerto’s arresting main tune. The middle movement is a distilled ‘song without words’, and the last frolics and celebrates with the lightness of a soufflé.

— Andrew Mellor © 2025

Andrew Mellor is author of The Northern Silence: Journeys in Nordic Music and Culture (Yale University Press, 2022)

Gustav Mahler (1860-1911): Symphony No 1 in D major

  1. Langsam. Schleppend [Slow. Dragging] - Immer sehr gemächlich [Always at a very leisurely pace]
  2. Kräftig bewegt, doch nicht zu schnell [With strong movement, but not too fast] - Trio: Recht gemächlich [Quite leisurely] - Tempo primo
  3. Feierlich und gemessen, ohne zu schleppen [Solemn and measured, without dragging]
  4. Stürmisch bewegt [Stormy]

When Gustav Mahler began his First Symphony in 1884, 'modern music' meant Wagner, while the standard by which new symphonies were judged was that of Brahms, the arch 'classical-romantic'. In a Brahmsian symphony there was little room for Wagnerian lush harmonies, or sensational new orchestral colours. In fact the orchestral forces Brahms employed were basically the same as those used by Beethoven and Schubert in their symphonies, three-quarters of a century earlier.

So for audiences brought up on Brahms, hearing Mahler's First Symphony would have been like stepping into a new world. The opening can still surprise even today: one note, an A, is spread through almost the entire range of the string section, topped with ghostly violin harmonics. Other unusual colours follow: distant trumpet fanfares, high clarinet cuckoo-calls, a plaintive cor anglais, the bell-like bass notes of the harp. All this would have been startlingly new in Mahler's time. And there's nothing tentative or experimental about this symphonic debut: at twenty four, Mahler knows precisely the sound he wants, and precisely how to get it.

Still, there's much more to Mahler's First Symphony than innovative orchestral colours and effects. When the symphony was first performed it had a title, 'Titan' - taken from the once-famous novel by the German romantic writer Jean Paul (the pen name of Johann Paul Richter). For Richter the ‘Titan’, the true genius, is a ‘Heaven-Stormer’ (Himmelsstürmer) – an obsessive, almost recklessly passionate idealist. The idea appealed strongly to Mahler, but so too did Richter’s descriptions of landscapes. For the premiere, Mahler set out his version of the Titan theme in an explanatory programme note, which told how the symphony progressed from 'the awakening of nature at early dawn', through youthful happiness and love, to the sardonic gloom of the funeral march, and then to the finale, subtitled 'From Inferno to Paradise'. And it was clear that Mahler's interest in Richter's theme was more than literary. Behind the symphony, he hinted to friends, was the memory of a love affair that had ended, painfully, at about the time he began work on the symphony.

But Mahler soon began to lose faith in programmes. 'I would like it stressed that the symphony is greater than the love affair it is based on', he wrote. 'The real affair became the reason for, but by no means the true meaning of, the work'. In later life he could be blunt: when someone raised the subject at an evening drinks party, Mahler is said to have leapt to his feet and shouted, 'Perish all programmes!' But for most listeners, music that is so passionate, dramatic and so full of the sounds of nature can't be fully explained in the detached terms of ‘pure’ musical analysis. Fortunately the First Symphony is full of pointers to possible meanings beyond the notes. The main theme of the first movement - heard on cellos and basses after the slow, intensely atmospheric 'dawn' introduction - is taken from the second of Mahler's four Lieder eines fahrenden Gesellen ('Songs of a Wayfarer'), written as a 'memorial' to his affair with the singer Johanna Richter (no relation of the novelist, but the name-connection is striking). In the song, a young man, jilted in love, sets out on a beautiful spring morning, hoping that nature will help his own heart to heal. For most of the first movement, Mahler seems to share the young man's hope. The ending seems cheerful enough. But at the heart of the movement comes a darkly mysterious passage, echoing the 'dawn' introduction, but adding sinister new sounds: the low, quiet growl of a tuba, ominous drum-beats, and a repeated sighing figure for cellos. For a moment, the music seems to echo the final words of the song: 'So will my joy blossom too? No, no; it will never, never bloom again.'

Dance music dominates the second movement, especially the robust, earthy vigour of the Ländler (the country cousin of the sophisticated urban Waltz). There are hints here of another, earlier song, Hans und Grete, in which gawky young Hans finds a sweetheart at a village dance - all innocent happiness. But the slower, more reflective Trio brings more adult expression: nostalgia and, later, sarcasm (shrill high woodwind). The third movement is in complete contrast. This is an eerie, sardonic funeral march, partly inspired by a painting by Jacques Callot, 'The Huntsman’s Funeral', in which a procession of animals carry the hunter to his grave. One by one, the orchestral instruments enter quietly, playing a famous old nursery tune, 'Frère Jacques' – which sounds like another interesting name-connection, except that Austrians like Mahler would have known the tune to the words 'Brother Martin, are you sleeping?' At the heart of this movement, Mahler makes a lengthy quotation from the last of the Lieder eines fahrenden Gesellen. The song tells in soft, gentle tones of how a young man, stricken with grief at the loss of the girl he loves, finds consolation in the thought of death. This is the dark heart of the First Symphony.

But this is not the end of the story. In the finale Mahler strives onward—in the words of the discarded programme, 'From Inferno to Paradise'. At first all is turbulence, but when the storm has died down, strings present an ardent, slower melody - unmistakably a love theme. There's a brief memory of the first movement's 'dawn' music, then the struggle begins again. Eventually massed horns introduce a new, radiantly hopeful theme, strongly reminiscent of 'And he shall reign' from Handel's Messiah. More reminiscences and still more heroic struggles follow, until dark introspection is finally overcome, and the symphony ends in jubilation. Mahler's hero has survived to live, and love, another day.

— Stephen Johnson


Sir Antonio Pappano, Chief Conductor

Janine Jansen, violin

London Symphony Orchestra

London Symphony Orchestra

Chief Conductor: Sir Antonio Pappano
Conductor Emeritus: Sir Simon Rattle
Principal Guest Conductors: Gianandrea Noseda, François-Xavier Roth
Associate Artists: Barbara Hannigan, André J Thomas
Conductor Laureate: Michael Tilson Thomas

FIRST VIOLINS
Andrej Power, Leader
Cellerina Park
Clare Duckworth
Ginette Decuyper
Maxine Kwok
Stefano Mengoli
Claire Parfitt
Elizabeth Pigram
Laurent Quénelle
Harriet Rayfield
Olatz Ruiz de Gordejuela
Sylvain Vasseur
Dániel Mészöly
Hilary Jane Parker
Djumash Poulsen
Rhys Watkins

SECOND VIOLINS
Julián Gil Rodríguez
Thomas Norris
Miya Väisänen
Matthew Gardner
Naoko Keatley
Alix Lagasse
Belinda McFarlane
Iwona Muszynska
Csilla Pogány
Louise Shackelton
Ingrid Button
Mitzi Gardner
Polina Makhina
Shoshanah Sievers

VIOLAS
Eivind Ringstad
Gillianne Haddow
Malcolm Johnston
Thomas Beer
Steve Doman
Sofia Silva Sousa
Mizuho Ueyama
Regina Beukes
Michelle Bruil
Errika Collins
Philip Hall
Martin Schaefer



CELLOS
Rebecca Gilliver
Alastair Blayden
Salvador Bolón
Daniel Gardner
Amanda Truelove
Morwenna Del Mar
Silvestrs Kalniš
Ghislaine McMullin
Miwa Rosso
Peteris Sokolovskis

DOUBLE BASSES
Rodrigo Moro Martín
Patrick Laurence
Thomas Goodman
Chaemun Im
Joe Melvin
Jani Pensola
Simon Oliver
Colin Paris

FLUTES
Gareth Davies
Julien Beaudiment
Imogen Royce

PICCOLO
Patricia Moynihan

OBOES
Juliana Koch
Olivier Stankiewicz
Layla Baratto

COR ANGLAIS
Sarah Harper

CLARINETS
Sérgio Pires
Chris Richards
Chi-Yu Mo
Sonia Sielaff

BASS CLARINET
Ferran Garcerà Perelló

BASSOONS
Daniel Jemison
Todd Gibson-Cornish
Joost Bosdijk

 

CONTRA BASSOON
Martin Field

 HORNS
Diego Incertis Sánchez
Mihajlo Bulajic
Angela Barnes
Timothy Jones
Jonathan Maloney
Daniel Curzon
Meilyr Hughes
James Pillai 

 TRUMPETS
James Fountain
Thomas Fountain
Adam Wright
Katie Smith
Gerald Ruddock

TROMBONES
Merin Rhyd
Helen Vollam
Jonathan Hollick

BASS TROMBONE
Paul Milner

TUBA
Ben Thomson

TIMPANI
Nigel Thomas
Patrick King

PERCUSSION
Neil Percy
David Jackson
Sam Walton

HARP
Bryn Lewis

PIANO
Elizabeth Burley

LSO ADMIN
Dame Kathryn McDowell DBE DL, Managing Director
Frankie Sheridan, Tours Manager
Mary Phillips, Tours Manager
Emily Rutherford, Personnel Manager
Kenneth Chung, Librarian
Fern Wilson, Stage Manager
Jakub Drewa, Stage Manager
Liana Richards, Director of Advancement
Becky Lees, Head of LSO Live
Chris Millard, Head of Press & External Affairs

 

With special thanks to the LSO’s 2025 US Tour Syndicate, who have helped to make our visit possible. We would also like to extend our thanks to those who support the wider work of the LSO through the American LSO Foundation


Acknowledgments

This performance is sponsored by: